In a Facebook post on September 27, 2023, the Holmes County Sheriff's Office reported that they, along with the U.S. Marshals Caribbean Task Force, received information that Warren Culp, Jr., wanted out of Jefferson County, was staying at the Holiday Inn Express in Bonifay. The post states: "Culp had active warrants for scheme to defraud and had made statements that he would make law enforcement kill him. Upon arrival at the hotel, deputies found Culp's vehicle in the parking lot and confirmed with hotel staff that he had checked in. Shortly after, Culp was seen looking out the window of his room, then walked to the parking lot. HCSO personnel made contact with Culp in the parking lot and quickly took him into custody."
Warren Culp, Jr., was transported to the Holmes County Jail to await extradition to Jefferson County.
